The price of Authenticity

.
How to wear a baseball shirt | outfit inspiration | style: Berlin, Athleisure, sportswear, white pants, comfy, sporty, Feminism slogan jacket | Brands: Laurel, Dodgers, Nakd

First of all, a disclaimer: I don’t watch baseball, and I don’t really know much about it. But what I do know is that it’s important to throw well and hard, and that there’s a little ball involved. Well, that’s about the extent of my knowledge. I think I probably know roughly as much about baseball as the average American knows about what we call football and they call soccer. It involves a ball, and a goal.
 
All that said, I wear a Dodgers shirt. And I don’t even know what city the team is based in, let alone what league it plays in.
 
Well, I know a good deal more about football/soccer: I know most of the players, I even understood by know what it means that a ball is in the out, and I watch the most important games.
 
Still, I wear a baseball and not a football shirt. Why?

How to wear a baseball shirt | outfit inspiration | style: Berlin, Athleisure, sportswear, white pants, comfy, sporty, Feminism slogan jacket | Brands: Laurel, Dodgers, Nakd

How to wear a baseball shirt | outfit inspiration | style: Berlin, Athleisure, sportswear, white pants, comfy, sporty, Feminism slogan jacket | Brands: Laurel, Dodgers, Nakd

The honest answer: I think football shirts and jerseys are ugly – especially those of my favorite team. And I’m not up for getting involved in too many discussions on the subject – it just seems to be such an emotionally charged subject. Not many people take football lightly here in Germany. Whereas it’s ok to be an atheist and still wear a cross for fashion reasons, tolerance levels are much lower when it comes to football. I’m not even sure if I’d be considered worthy enough to wear my team’s shirt, being the casual fan I am. I’d probably face some criticism along those lines. As I said: an emotionally charged subject.
 
Either way, I think it’s totally fine to wear a baseball shirt.
 
I like it. That’s literally the only reason. The question is not: does this make me more or rather less credible?

Yesterday, I was invited to attend a panel discussion organized by Instagram , a workshop or sorts, where I presented something like the aggregated influencer’s viewpoint on the subject of mobile marketing. We discussed the various possibilities to widen reach via different channels. The consensus we reached was this: quality and authenticity are everything. But reach and target group orientation are also crucial for the booking of an influencer and the campaigns he will be assigned with.

How to wear a baseball shirt | outfit inspiration | style: Berlin, Athleisure, sportswear, white pants, comfy, sporty, Feminism slogan jacket | Brands: Laurel, Dodgers, Nakd

Quality.
 
Authenticity.
 
Reach.
 
Target Group.

Those are the key points, the crucial factors.
But what do they mean? How do I stay authentic as an influencer?

In my opinion, there are only two ways to stay authentic.
 
1. If you have a wide reach, you can’t post too many advertisements (no infomercial), you need to know your target group very well (and take it into account), and you need to be willing to go against the grain from time to time.
 
2. If your reach is rather limited, and you are not branded yet. That automatically makes you more authentic.

The fact that authenticity and reach are very often quite divergent concepts is apparent in the case of many major influencers. For example, do you still really believe Chiara when she tells you that this or that product is the best thing ever? I have my doubts. Today it’s this brand, tomorrow the competition. Still, many follow her, mainly because they think her life is exciting. Many bloggers advertise, but do you still believe them when they recite company slogans straight into the camera? It’s easier for smaller bloggers: they’re not so appropriated by a long run of cooperations, which can make it easier for them to get better results.

How to wear a baseball shirt | outfit inspiration | style: Berlin, Athleisure, sportswear, white pants, comfy, sporty, Feminism slogan jacket | Brands: Laurel, Dodgers, Nakd

How to wear a baseball shirt | outfit inspiration | style: Berlin, Athleisure, sportswear, white pants, comfy, sporty, Feminism slogan jacket | Brands: Laurel, Dodgers, Nakd

Jacke: Nakd
Hose: Laurèl
Sandalen: Laurèl


These two factors are seemingly mutually exclusive:
 
if your reach is big, you won’t be perceived as very authentic.
 
And if you stay authentic, your reach will be limited.
 
But is it possible to be authentic AND have a wide reach?
 
I asked myself that question after yesterday’s panel as I was editing the pictures that illustrate this post.
My answer is: YES.
 
There are many positive examples out there, after all, the Dandy’s, Jane’s of this world, DariaDaria or, in the American sphere, Leandra Medine.
 
They all share a common quality: they sometimes address unpleasant subjects.
 
And another one: they are all from a slightly older generation of bloggers. They did not blow up on Instagram, the became popular because of their messages.

I would like to see myself in their tradition. I try my best to be authentic and honest with you. That comes at a price. While I am not constantly dealing with lawsuits like the Dandy’s, but there are incidents like the other day when I was harshly reproached by a former cooperation partner because I talked about the negative aspects of our work together in my podcast. I didn’t even criticize the company or the product, more the circumstances. Well, they were not amused. And in turn I was pretty pissed off too, because I didn’t find their criticism justified at all. I wanted to explain that that’s the price one has to pay for authenticity sometimes. And that things like that can happen if you work with bloggers and not with models.

How to wear a baseball shirt | outfit inspiration | style: Berlin, Athleisure, sportswear, white pants, comfy, sporty, Feminism slogan jacket | Brands: Laurel, Dodgers, Nakd

In times of professionalization, companies sometimes forget why the book bloggers in the first place: because of their personality, and their opinions. If you provide neither, if you turn like a flag in the breeze, you may be more popular with agencies, but you won’t be authentic – would you agree? Is the majority of bloggers already completely flexible in their opinions for the sake of collaboration deals?
 
In the workshop, one brand made a point with a campaign they’d been running. 3 bloggers said the product slogan into the camera, with their widest Hollywood smiles. Photoshop skills, 1000 points. The wooden acting just made everyone laugh.
 
‘In terms of authenticity we have come a long way since’, the company’s rep went on to tell us in the workshop. ‘Today we’d do it very differently’.

 

There is hope, still.

.

This post is also available in German Russian



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

12 Comments


  1. Nur btw, die Jacke ist schon in meinem Einkaufskorb haha. Nein wirklich, ich liebe die und sehe sie nicht zum ersten mal, die Sachen von NA-KD sind sowieso total cool und diese Jacke habe ich vom ersten Augenblick geliebt!
    Liebe Grüße,
    Sandra / http://shineoffashion.com

    Reply

    1. Aber bevor du sie bestellst benutze den Code damit du sie 20% günstiger bekommst mit mashas20!!

      Reply

  2. Hi Masha,

    es ist schön zu hören, dass da endlich ein Umdenken stattfindet. Ich finde auch, dass sich Authentizität und Reichweite nicht ausschließen. Ich glaube aber, die Follower bekommen schnell ein Gefühl dafür, wer es ist und wer nicht, oder?

    Und du hast recht, wenn man keine Authentizität will, sollte man Models buchen. Da sehe ich auch Instagram-Stars wie Chiara. Die haben einfach die Branche gewechselt ohne ihre Berufsbezeichnung zu ändern. :)

    Liebe Grüße
    Eve von http://www.eveblogazine.com

    Reply

    1. Hi Eve,

      naja, was heisst Umdenken. Man kann es hoffen, aber am Ende ist das eben der Markt und eine Tatsache, mit der man arbeiten muss. Ich habe auch keine Lust mehr mich dem romantischen Glauben hinzugeben, dass sich Qualität und Ehrlichkeit durchsetzt, denn leider tut sie das nur selten. Jeder muss für sich selbst entscheiden, wie er seine Seite führen will und ich persönlich mag einen Blog wie den der genannten Mädels mehr, als den von großen Instagram Stars!

      Reply

  3. It’s from my city, Los Angeles! Sorry I just had to do a shoutout right there! LA Dodgers (recently had a game against the San Francisco Giants actually!). I don’t really like sports conversations either, which is why I usually avoid most of the merchandise. But also just wanted to say that where I’m from, even if you aren’t a sports fan, local teams become more a way of representing where you are from.

    I appreciate what you said about authenticity 100%, but I did chuckle a little because of the fact that you are wearing in some ways a piece of clothing that could be hugely symbolic to some people just for the fashion of it. Symbolic precisely because it is rooted to local pride. Your lack
    of care for that thus does not necessarily convey ‘authenticity’ as you might say, although it was very authentic of you to graciously, honestly admit ignorance. I guess in Europe, there would also be little reason to know that either. :)

    I love your style, but just had to say that as a proud LA resident. I guess now you know what the logo means. ;)

    (Also, this might be deeper than needed, but can any image be so called free from these conversations? Can any image lack symbolism? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ )

    Reply

    1. hahahah sorry :DDD

      And yeah maybe you’re right :D
      I knew it’s a tough topic^^

      Reply

  4. I only blog to talk. That is the main reason I read blogs too. Conversation. If there is none and it is all just cash and adverts right and left – I am gone, no matter how lovely the person behind the blog could potentially be. For me blogging is a space to exchange opinions…
    .. but I do understand for some it can be a little version of their favourite magazines.Why not? It will just be me-less :)

    Reply

    1. I think that’s the original idea of blogging, before it became a sponsoring platform. I feel the same way and I prefer to READ blogs, more than just to look at them :)

      Seems like we have this in common!

      Reply
X
- Enter Your Location -
- or -
SUBSCRIBE TO MY NEWSLETTER
Later
Thanks for signing up. You must confirm your email address before we can send you. Please check your email and follow the instructions.
Your Email is safe and will never be forwarded to 3rd parties.
Don't miss out. Subscribe today.
×
×

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close